[Beowulf] Intel quad core nodes?
jan.heichler at gmx.net
Tue Oct 9 13:38:25 EDT 2007
Montag, 8. Oktober 2007, meintest Du:
BW> I'm moving towards setting up a small cluster (my first), and am
BW> thinking about using Intel quad core processors. However, I'm a little
BW> concerned about memory contention. I'm (tentatively) going to have one
BW> processor per node (this appears to be the cheapest way to go), but I
BW> still wonder whether four cores will choke Intel's memory architecture.
BW> (AMD's Barcelona may be better in this regard, but it doesn't seem to be
BW> available yet, at least not through retail channels).
Yes intel does have a memory bandwidth problem....
BW> I'd like to hear any opinions on this issue. And if you've used quad
BW> core processors, I'd certainly like to hear about your experiences
BW> (including which processor you've used).
... but it does not to affect performance as hard as one could think.
How big the impact is depends mostly on your application. I saw code
scaling very good (HPL for example ;-) ) and others where you just get
10% more out of using 8 instead of 4 cores (on a dual socket quadcore
Another aspect that you should think of is the i/o intensity of your
application. Remember that 4 cores in a single socket system will
share the same interconnect port. That could hit performance pretty
bad. A high speed interconnect could be a solution to that problem but
will cost you money.
Conclusion: the only good benchmark is your own application. The Intel
DualCore performs quite good on a wide range of applications. The
QuadCore performs good on some of 'em - but as you said: it seems to
be the only available (through retail channels) quadcore to the market right now...
Beowulf mailing list, Beowulf at beowulf.org
To change your subscription (digest mode or unsubscribe) visit http://www.beowulf.org/mailman/listinfo/beowulf
More information about the Beowulf