[Beowulf] dedupe filesystem
hahn at mcmaster.ca
Fri Jun 5 10:22:55 EDT 2009
>>> The best of both worlds would certainly be a central, fast storage
>>> filesystem, coupled with a hierarchical storage management system.
>> I'm not sure - is there some clear indication that one level of storage is
>> not good enough?
> I guess it strongly depends on your workload and applications. If your users
> tend to keep all their files for long-term purposes, as Bogdan Costescu
> pertinently described earlier, it might make sense to transparently free up
> the fast centralized filesystem and move the unused-at-the-moment-but-still-
> crucially-important files to a slower, farther filesystem (or tapes).
no: my point concerned only whether there is a meaningful distinction
between what you call fast and slow storage. from a hardware perspective,
there is can be differences in latency, though probably not noticed by
anything other than benchmarks or quite specialized apps. there can also
be aggregate throughput differences: an OST on QDR IB vs Gb.
so, an open question: do HPC people still buy high-end disks (small FC/SAS
disks, usually also 10-15k)? we're putting them in our next MDS, but
certainly not anywhere else.
another question: do HPC people still buy tapes? I'm personally opposed,
but some apparently reasonable people find them comforting (oddly, because
they can to some limited extent be taken offline.)
>> this seems like a bad design to me. I would think (and I'm reasonably
>> familiar with Lustre, though not an internals expert) that if you're going
>> to touch Lustre interfaces at all, you should simply add cheaper,
>> higher-density OSTs, and make more intelligent placement/migration
> In Lustre, that would be done through OST pools. Eh, isn't this also a feature
> CEA contributed to? :)
is there a documented, programmatic lustre interface to control OST placement
(other than lfs setstripe)? such an interface would also need a
high-performance way to query the MDS directly (not through the mounted
FS, which is too slow for any seriously large FS.)
Beowulf mailing list, Beowulf at beowulf.org sponsored by Penguin Computing
To change your subscription (digest mode or unsubscribe) visit http://www.beowulf.org/mailman/listinfo/beowulf
More information about the Beowulf