Xbox clusters?

Brian LaMere blamere at
Wed Dec 5 18:40:01 EST 2001

I spent less than $100,000 on a 48 node dual-1ghz p3 cluster with 2gb ram
each, and hot-swappable 18gb 15krpm drives (all in a 1-U rackmounted
footprint!).  Of course, I cheated at the time (VA linux firesale)...but I
could do the same thing again for about $125,000 in today's prices with
systems that someone else builds, and has a year warranty., for instance.  For $2537, you get dual p3- 1ghz cpu,
18gb 10krpm hotswap scsi, and 2 gb ram.  All in a 1-U package, all with a 1
year warranty.  Extended warranties available.

Why the hell use HP/IBM/Compaq?  Cost almost 3 times as much.  If I put
together at 100 node advancedclustering cluster, for the same HP price
you'll make a ~40 node cluster.  So...I can have half of my systems be dead
at any one point and be waiting for replacement, and /still/ have far more
systems online.

And as has been stated...I could build the darn things myself even cheaper.
Xbox's have a small footprint - that's in their favor.  Not much else in
their favor though.  People spend $250,000 on 40-node clusters cause
well...their goofy.  That simple, really.  And footprint is very important.
I have 48 nodes in one rack (extended height).  Rent for the floorspace I
suse is low, and I can still get to them all easy.  You don't want a
medium-sized or larger cluster with regular cases, I wouldn't think.


-----Original Message-----
From: Velocet [mailto:math at]
Sent: Wednesday, November 28, 2001 11:40 AM
To: beowulf at
Subject: Re: Xbox clusters?

On Wed, Nov 28, 2001 at 02:04:55PM -0500, Velocet's all...
> On Wed, Nov 28, 2001 at 12:50:46PM -0500, Josip Loncaric's all...
> > Microsoft's Xbox packages a 733 MHz Pentium III, 64 megabytes of memory,
> > a DVD drive, 100 Mbps Ethernet, and an 8-gigabyte hard disk for about
> > $300.  This would make it a reasonably powerful cluster node with an
> > excellent price/performance ratio.  Of course, the thing runs a
> > slimmed-down variant of Windows 2000 instead of Linux, but has anyone
> > discussed making an Xbox cluster?
> Why bother when for about $300 USD you can put together a
> cluster node with a 1.333GHz athlon with 256Mb of DDR ram?
> Sides, who brought 'price/performance' onto this list? Dont know thats
never a
> factor on the beowulf list? :)

So, the question is, with these numbers, how do people end up spending
$250K on 40 or even 60-CPU clusters?

Beowulf mailing list, Beowulf at
To change your subscription (digest mode or unsubscribe) visit
Beowulf mailing list, Beowulf at
To change your subscription (digest mode or unsubscribe) visit

More information about the Beowulf mailing list